I think they work really well if you are actually trying to tension a single speed drivetrain. I think it is also a bonus that you can buy them without a dropout hanger. It just looks soooo clean.
I would maybe worry that the rocking style don’t have enough swing to fully tension a single speed. But, I have no actual experience with them.
For road I run dingle speed and can get a 14/16 combo in under 15mm of adjustment.
I rode an El mariachi for a long time and adjustment was never an issue but on the MTB I never change ratios. On the road I switch ratios frequently depending on fitness, elevation and who I am riding with.
I think I’m going to use the sliders. I hope they make a slightly cleaner/lighter looking rear end. I am concerned the rockers will look busy and bulky.
Personally I think that rockers actually look better than sliders would with the steep seat stay angle. Like it makes for a lighter and more open rear end or something. I love Sliders on hardtails with a low SS angle but on road geo I feel like they can end up looking a bit awkward. Have a look at the Soma Wolverine to get an idea of what I mean.
Also if you want to use flat mount brakes then the rocker insert and CS routing will look a lot cleaner too! Paragon do make a flat mount sliding insert but the limitation of that design make it look like a bit of a workaround.
If you are considering fenders, and why wouldn’t you, consider using an eccentric bottom bracket instead. That way your fender clearances aren’t screwed up by adjusting chain length.
The rocker dropouts from paragon are elegant in that they barely change the height of the wheel. All the other rocker designs will change your wheel height (or rotate the frame geometry depending on how you look at it). This may or may not bother you. Unfortunately, they tend to slip under single speed use, so Dave Levy came up with a additional widget that fixes that problem.
Hahn Rossman
@brad I’ve used an eccentric designed for PF30 or BB30 shells. Like this one: https://www.jbi.bike/site/product_details.php?part_number=11050
So, the usual precautions are heatsink, reamer, etc. Just like if you were making a frame for that standard.
They are available in GXP, or 24mm wtc.
Hahn Rossman
Somehow that is one of my most ridden but least photographed bikes. It’s a classic touring geo, built flat bar but could easily be run with drops and a shortish stem.